Too often, businesses make small but costly errors when setting up or managing their fleet insurance coverage. These missteps can lead to higher premiums, denied claims, or unexpected gaps that leave you unprotected when an accident happens. Knowing the most common pitfalls will help you avoid them and keep your fleet properly covered.
In this article, we’ll look at five common mistakes companies make with fleet insurance in Ontario, how to avoid them, and how Levitt can help you secure the most competitive fleet insurance quotes for your operation.
Mistake 1: Treating Fleet Vehicles Like Personal Cars
One of the biggest errors businesses make is insuring fleet vehicles the same way they would their own personal cars. Standard home and auto insurance policies aren’t designed for commercial use, and relying on them leaves serious gaps in coverage.
Ontario’s Compulsory Automobile Insurance Act requires all vehicles on the road to have valid insurance, but businesses need more than just basic liability. Fleets face higher exposure to accidents, cargo damage, and liability claims. That’s why a proper commercial fleet insurance policy is essential.
A well-structured fleet policy covers not only third-party liability but also collision, comprehensive, accident benefits, and often extras like non-owned automobile coverage for employees using rental or borrowed vehicles. Treating fleet vehicles like personal ones can leave your business financially exposed.
Mistake 2: Failing to Disclose Vehicle Use
Insurers in Ontario base premiums on how vehicles are actually used. If you understate mileage, leave out cross-border trips, or fail to mention cargo types, you may find your coverage invalid when you need it most.
For example:
- A plumbing company that doesn’t disclose carrying tools and equipment daily
- A courier business that leaves out the fact it regularly crosses into the U.S.
- A seasonal operator that fails to note winter downtime
Accurate disclosure ensures your insurer prices risk correctly and your claims are honoured. Brokers like Levitt help clarify these details upfront so you don’t face coverage disputes later.
Mistake 3: Ignoring Driver Risk Management
Your drivers are just as important to your premiums as your vehicles. Insurers in Ontario look at driver history, license class, and claims records when calculating commercial insurance for fleets.
Common mistakes include:
- Not screening drivers for traffic convictions or accident history
- Failing to provide ongoing training
- Allowing inexperienced drivers to operate specialized vehicles without oversight
A single driver with a poor record can affect the entire fleet’s premium. By implementing driver training, safety programs, and performance monitoring, businesses reduce accidents and qualify for better rates. Some insurers even offer incentives for fleets that take proactive steps in managing driver risk.
Mistake 4: Overlooking Coverage for Seasonal or Idle Vehicles
Many Ontario businesses operate fleets seasonally, such as landscaping trucks in summer, snowplows in winter, or delivery vans during peak holiday months. One mistake is paying for full coverage year-round when vehicles sit unused for months.
A proper commercial fleet insurance policy can be adjusted to reflect seasonal use, sometimes reducing costs by placing certain vehicles under comprehensive-only coverage when not in use.
On the flip side, some businesses go too far and cancel coverage entirely when vehicles are idle. This can be risky, as theft, vandalism, or weather damage can occur even when vehicles are parked. Brokers help strike the right balance so you only pay for the coverage you truly need.
Mistake 5: Choosing Price Over Value
It’s tempting to chase the lowest premium, especially when managing a large fleet. But focusing solely on cost can backfire. Cheaper policies often exclude critical protections or come with high deductibles that create financial strain after an accident.
In Ontario, insurers are required to provide certain minimum coverages, but the real value comes in how well a policy is tailored to your business. For example:
- Do you need cargo coverage for goods in transit?
- Do you require higher liability limits for cross-border operations?
- Are you protected if employees use rented vehicles for company business?
The right policy balances affordability with comprehensive protection. Working with a broker ensures you’re comparing apples to apples, not just picking the cheapest option.
Why These Mistakes Happen
Most businesses don’t intentionally cut corners. These mistakes happen because:
- Fleet insurance is more complex than personal auto coverage
- Ontario regulations can be confusing without expert guidance
- Business owners and managers are busy running operations and assume their current coverage is “good enough”
Unfortunately, these assumptions can lead to costly surprises when a claim is denied or a premium spikes unexpectedly.
How to Avoid These Mistakes
Avoiding these common errors comes down to three steps:
- Work with a knowledgeable broker – Brokers compare multiple fleet insurance quotes and explain coverage differences.
- Review policies annually – Businesses evolve. Fleets grow or shrink, routes change, and new risks emerge.
- Invest in risk management – From driver training to telematics, insurers reward proactive businesses with lower premiums.
Fleet insurance is not one-size-fits-all. Mistakes like treating vehicles as personal cars, failing to disclose use, ignoring driver management, overlooking seasonal coverage, or focusing only on price can leave Ontario businesses vulnerable.
By understanding these pitfalls and working with an experienced broker, you can secure fleet insurance in Ontario that protects your business vehicles, drivers, and bottom line.
At Levitt, we specialize in helping businesses get comprehensive commercial insurance for fleets at competitive rates. We know how to position your business to insurers, avoid unnecessary risks, and make sure you only pay for the coverage you need.
Don’t let simple mistakes cost your business thousands.
request a fleet insurance quote book a call with a brokerYes
No
Somewhat